VZV myelitis with secondary HIV CSF escape
- 1 Neurology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA
- 2 Infectious Diseases, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA
- Correspondence to Dr Lydia Barakat; lydia.barakat@yale.edu
Abstract
A 52-year-old woman with HIV and recent antiretroviral therapy non-adherence presented with a 5-day history of widespread painful vesicular skin lesions. Direct fluorescent antibody testing of the skin lesions was positive for varicella zoster virus (VZV). On day 3, she developed profound right upper extremity weakness. MRI of the brain and cervical spine was suggestive of VZV myelitis. Lumbar puncture was positive for VZV PCR in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and CSF HIV viral load was detected at 1030 copies/mL, indicating ‘secondary’ HIV CSF escape. She was treated with intravenous acyclovir for 4 weeks and subsequent oral therapy with famciclovir then valacyclovir for 6 weeks. She also received dexamethasone. The patient had an almost full recovery at 6 months. Myelitis is a rare complication of reactivated VZV infection that can have atypical presentation in immunocompromised patients. Such ‘secondary’ HIV CSF escape should be considered in immunosuppressed patients with concomitant central nervous system infection.
Background
Varicella zoster virus (VZV) may rarely spread to the central nervous system (CNS), causing viral myelitis, most commonly affecting immunocompromised patients.1 2 Paraparesis with sensory-level impairment is common in VZV transverse myelitis, and typically occurs 1–3 weeks following development of the rash.3 However, cases of VZV myelitis occurring without the rash and up to 5 months following the rash have been reported.4 Though not always abnormal, patients with VZV myelitis often present with signs of neuroinflammation, including elevated opening pressure, pleocytosis and elevated protein.3 VZV is often detected by PCR in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF).
In people with HIV, HIV RNA may be detected in CSF. When HIV RNA in CSF is detectable in the setting of plasma HIV RNA levels <50 copies/mL, or when HIV RNA in CSF is >1 log higher than HIV RNA level in plasma, this is termed CSF ‘escape’.5 When CSF escape occurs in association with a non-HIV CNS infection, such as VZV myelitis, it is classified as ‘secondary’ CSF escape.5 CSF escape is associated with a variety of neurological symptoms, including impairment in cognition as well as motor and sensory function.
Case presentation
A 52-year-old black woman with a history of HIV-1 infection presented with a 5-day history of widespread painful vesicular skin lesions primarily concentrated on the right arm and hand, with lesions also present on the shoulder, nose, breast, back, groin and abdomen. Her medical history included HIV infection diagnosed almost 15 years earlier; 1 month prior to presentation, the CD4 T lymphocyte count was 703 cells/mL and the HIV RNA viral load was 16 600 copies/mL. The patient had a history of intermittent non-adherence to antiretrviral therapy (ART) for 6 months prior to this presentation, reportedly due to lack of adequate food source to take with her new ART regimen of elvitegravir/cobicistat/emtricitabine/tenofovir DF. She had a remote history of cytomegalovirus (CMV) retinitis, herpes simplex virus-1 (HSV-1), genital trichomonas and chlamydia, latent tuberculosis, dermatomal herpes zoster, history of prior cocaine abuse, depression and chronic back pain. She had no recent ill contacts or travel.
On admission, the patient appeared anxious, but vital signs were within normal range. A vesicular rash with erythematous base, which was painful with associated burning and tingling, was observed, predominantly confined to the right arm and hand in a primarily C5–C7 dermatomal distribution (figure 1). Two vesicles were noted on the abdomen, one crossing the midline. A possible lesion on the nose and several lesions on either side of the midline on the abdomen and left breast were seen. A rash was also seen on the back of the head and axilla. Right upper extremity strength was limited due to pain. Other aspects of the physical examination, including cardiopulmonary and neurological examination, were unremarkable. She was started on intravenous acyclovir while awaiting confirmatory direct fluorescent antibody (DFA) testing of a skin lesion swab for VZV and HSV-1, and her outpatient ART was resumed. DFA testing of the skin lesion was positive for VZV and negative for HSV-1 and 2.
(A) Vesicular rash with erythematous base in a C5–C7 dermatomal distribution over the right arm and hand on day 1. (B) Vesicles coalescing and crusting over the right arm and hand on day 3.
On hospital day 3, she developed profound right upper extremity weakness and could not raise her right arm against gravity, along with weakened neck flexion and extension. On neurological examination, her mental status examination was normal, including normal orientation, comprehension, speech, following commands, naming, repetition, attention and recall. She had a left ptosis and sluggish left pupil. She had weakness in the right upper extremity with 2–3/5 power proximally (biceps and deltoid) and 4/5 power distally at the triceps, wrist and finger flexors. Hip flexion and extension were 4+/5 bilaterally. Power was otherwise 5/5 throughout. The plantar response was extensor on the left. Sensation was intact. The remainder of the examination was normal.
Investigations
Her initial baseline laboratory data were significant for white blood cells (WBC) 5.0×109/L (reference range (ref) 4.0–10. 0) and haematocrit 44.4% (ref 37.0–47.0). Serum glucose was 106 mg/dL (ref 70–100), blood, urea, nitrogen (BUN) 22 mg/dL (ref 7–20), BUN/creatinine ratio 36.7 (ref 10.0–20.0) and chloride 95 mmol/L (ref 96–106); other routine laboratory studies were normal. CD4 T cell count was 132 cells/μL (ref 417–1612), plasma HIV viral load was 53 copies/mL and VZV DFA was positive.
MRI of the brain and cervical spine was conducted on hospital day 4 after the onset of right hemiparesis, which revealed abnormal hyperintense T2 signal from C2 to C6 with mild cord expansion, which was slightly asymmetrical, involving more of the right hemicord (figure 2). This lesion was associated with nodular and linear enhancement in the posterior and ventral aspects of the spinal cord. On brain MRI, symmetrical abnormal hyperintense T2 and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery signal was observed within the anterior and medial temporal lobes, with minimal hyperintense signal in the periventricular and subcortical cerebral white matter (figure 3).
T2 MRI of the cervical spine demonstrating expansive T2 bright lesion from C2 to C6, seen on (A) sagittal and (B) axial images. Arrows indicate the lesion. Panel (A) is most representative image.
Axial T2 MRI of the brain. Arrows indicate the lesions.
A lumbar puncture was performed on day 4 of hospitalisation; the opening pressure was 27 cmH2O (ref 6–25). Examination of the CSF revealed significant pleocytosis of 82 WBC per microliter (ref 0–5) with 2% neutrophils and 93% lymphocytes, glucose 50 mg/dL (ref 40–70), and protein 110 mg/dL (ref <50). CSF CMV, HSV, Epstein-Barr virus and John Cunningham virus PCR were negative. CSF Gram stain, bacterial and fungal cultures were negative. The venereal disease research laboratory test in the CSF was non-reactive, and the cryptococcal antigen test was also negative. VZV PCR was positive in the CSF. The HIV CSF viral load was found to be 1030 copies/mL. Plasma HIV viral load measured on the following day was 53 copies/mL.
Treatment
Intravenous acyclovir was continued, and intravenous dexamethasone was started due to suspicion for VZV myelitis and possible temporal lobe encephalitis. Over the next 4 days, her right upper extremity and bilateral lower extremity strength improved, and the vesicles began coalescing and crusting.
On day 8 of the hospitalisation, a repeat brain MRI showed stable to minimally improved signal abnormality involving the medial temporal lobes, inferior frontal lobes, as well as subinsular and periatrial white matter. Cervical spine MRI demonstrated mild improvement in the intramedullary signal abnormality in the spinal cord extending from C2 through C5–C6.
She was discharged on day 9 on intravenous acyclovir and oral dexamethasone. At discharge, motor strength was modestly improved: right deltoid 2/5, right biceps 2/5, right triceps 4+/5, right wrist flexion 4+/5, right wrist extension 4/5 and right hand grip 4+/5. Left arm, all 5/5. Sensation was intact.
Outcome and follow-up
The patient completed a total of 4 weeks of intravenous acyclovir followed by 2 weeks of oral famciclovir and then 4 weeks of valacyclovir, for a total of 10 weeks of antiviral therapy. Strength continued to improve except for persistent right deltoid weakness. Three months after the initial admission, CD4 T cell count was 748, plasma viral load was 87 copies/mL and lumbar puncture showed mild lymphocytic-predominant pleocytosis (23 WBC/µL, 100% lymphocytes), CSF HIV viral load of 22 copies/mL and undetectable VZV by PCR. Valacyclovir was discontinued. An electromyography and nerve conduction study performed at 5 months showed right C5 radiculopathy, likely due to residual injury from VZV myelitis. At 6 months, strength was 3/5 in the right deltoid and 4+/5 in the right biceps, but otherwise full strength. She had no sensory deficits. The area of the rash on her upper right arm remained painful, and she also had intermittent numbness and tingling in the fingers of her right hand, consistent with postviral neuropathy. An MRI of the cervical spine 7 months after presentation showed resolution of the meningeal enhancement and cervical cord signal abnormality.
Discussion
Herpes zoster is known to recur in immunocompromised patients, and severe complications of VZV infection can occur in HIV-infected patients. These include infections of the CNS (ie, myelitis) and ocular manifestations (ie, herpes zoster ophthalmicus and herpes retinitis).1 Major complications of herpes zoster are more likely to occur in patients with a low CD4 T lymphocyte count (<200 cells/mm3).2 Our patient had a recent rapid decline in CD4 T cell count due to intermittent ART adherence, despite CD4 count greater than 700 cells/μL as recently as 2 months prior to her presentation.
Rarely, myelitis may complicate acute reactivated VZV infection, most often in an immunocompromised individual. In these patients, myelitis more frequently presents with an insidious and progressive course and can be fatal. Typically, myelitis develops 1–3 weeks after the development of the rash.3 However, VZV myelitis in an HIV-infected patient can also present before or even without an accompanying rash.4 MRI can show mild expansion of the spinal cord in VZV myelitis,1 most frequently with long segments of increased hyperintense T2 signal along the cord.6 Our patient’s clinical presentation and cervical cord neuroimaging findings were classic for VZV myelitis. In addition, the spread of VZV into the CNS can contribute to a demyelinating component, with lesions that are often small, located deep in the white matter or at the junctions of the grey and white matter.7 The virus appears to enter the spinal cord at levels contiguous with affected dorsal root ganglia and nerves.
Treatments for neurological manifestations of VZV are primarily derived from case reports and expert opinion due to lack of large studies. Treatment for VZV myelitis is generally recommended to include intravenous acyclovir and steroids; however, there is no consensus on the duration of treatment for either, nor regarding the use of oral antivirals, such as famciclovir or valacyclovir, following intravenous acyclovir.8 9 We treated our patient with 4 weeks of intravenous acyclovir followed by 6 weeks of oral antivirals, as well as 10 days of steroids. Dexamethasone was chosen due to its relatively high anti-inflammatory activity and absence of mineralocorticoid activity. In this case, we continued oral antivirals for 6 weeks due to persistent, profound arm weakness and CD4 count less than 200 cells/μL.
In VZV myelitis, CSF can be either normal or demonstrate mild pleocytosis with a normal or mild elevation in protein level.3 In this current case, our patient had several hallmarks of neuroinflammation, including elevated opening pressure, pleocytosis and elevated protein. Microbial testing not only revealed a positive VZV PCR test, but also a CSF HIV RNA level approximately 20 times (1.5 log) higher than that in peripheral blood, indicating HIV CSF escape accompanying the VZV myelitis. This relatively unstudied type of viral CSF escape is termed ‘secondary’ CSF escape, which is defined by an increase in HIV CSF replication in association with a concomitant non-HIV CNS infection and/or inflammation.5
T2 hyperintense changes in white matter on brain MRI have been observed in cases of HIV CSF escape;10 it is possible that the seemingly asymptomatic temporal lobe lesions on our patient may have stemmed from a response to HIV escape rather than direct VZV infection. Due to the paucity of cases reported in the literature on secondary HIV CSF escape in the setting of herpes zoster, it remains unclear whether localised HIV replication in the CNS plays a role in the severity of zoster reactivation or whether the VZV infection facilitates HIV replication in the CNS.11 Notably, one recent study indicated that HIV replication in the CNS seen in secondary CSF escape is driven by an inflammatory response to VZV reactivation.12 This suggests that VZV, and likely other neurotropic viruses, such as HSV, should be considered in any patient with HIV CSF escape and relevant symptomatology.
In our patient’s case, the CSF escape resolved 3 months after the initial presentation, following treatment with acyclovir as well as continuation of ART that had been restarted on admission. The natural history of secondary HIV CSF escape is not well studied, but if production of HIV RNA in this condition is stimulated by inflammation incited by an independent pathogen, treatment of the alternate pathogen may be a key intervention to control HIV replication in the CNS during ART. Furthermore, such cases should be followed up with a lumbar puncture to ensure resolution of HIV CSF escape, as local HIV replication in the CNS can lead to mutations and CNS HIV resistance.
Learning points
-
Varicella zoster virus myelitis most often occurs 1–3 weeks following the rash, but can occur without a rash or months following the rash.
-
In patients with HIV, neurological complications of infection can lead to secondary HIV cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) escape. CSF should be analysed to assess for potential HIV CSF escape.
-
HIV CSF escape can cause a variety of neurological symptoms and associated radiological findings in the brain and spine MRI.
-
Although HIV CSF escape may cause a variety of symptoms, clinicians should consider other central nervous system (CNS) infections as the potential cause of a patient’s symptoms, as symptomatology may not be directly related to HIV CSF escape and may indeed be indicative of a primary infection driving HIV replication in the CNS.
Ethics statements
Acknowledgments
Timothy Hatcher was the patient’s primary infectious disease provider.
Footnotes
-
Twitter @JulianJWeiss
-
Contributors JJW: Drafting the manuscript. SS: Critical revision of the manuscript. LB: Critical revision of the manuscript.
-
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
-
Competing interests None declared.
-
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer-reviewed.
- © BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2021. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.
References
Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer